Google's spam policies have evolved significantly. The combination of algorithm updates targeting scaled link schemes (including AI-generated guest posts, link exchange networks, and paid placement disguised as editorial coverage), and the rollout of manual actions for "site reputation abuse," has eliminated entire categories of tactics that worked as recently as 2022.
What's left is a smaller, more defensible set of tactics that work because they produce links that reflect genuine editorial judgment. This guide covers what those tactics are, how to execute them at scale, and the realistic expectations for link acquisition in a more scrutinized environment.
Why Most Link Building Advice Is Obsolete
The bulk of link building content published before 2023 describes tactics built on loopholes that no longer exist or that carry unacceptable risk in 2026. Guest post networks have been decimated by Google's site reputation abuse policies. Private blog networks (PBNs) are detectable at scale and result in sitewide manual penalties. Paid link placements on "editorial" sites are increasingly identified by Google's machine learning systems, which now look at the pattern of a site's monetization, traffic sources, and link insertion timing.
The shift is fundamental: Google has gotten considerably better at evaluating whether a link reflects genuine editorial choice by an independent publisher, or whether it was placed in exchange for something (money, reciprocal links, content contribution). Links that fail this editorial test are either ignored or penalized. Links that pass it—because a real editor at a real publication decided your content or expertise was worth citing—carry meaningful authority.
This means link building in 2026 is more like PR than like technical optimization. The question isn't "how do we get more links?" but "how do we create things worth linking to, and how do we get them in front of the right people?"
Digital PR: The Highest-Leverage Tactic for Most Businesses
Digital PR is the practice of creating newsworthy content assets—original research, data studies, unique tools, expert commentary—and pitching them to journalists and editors who cover your industry. When a major publication covers your research, the resulting link carries substantial authoritative weight. A single link from a DA 70+ publication can move rankings in a way that 50 low-quality guest post links cannot.
Original data is the most consistently linkable digital PR asset. If you have access to proprietary data from your business operations, you can package it into a research study that journalists will cite. A managed SEO platform could publish an annual report on "The State of Small Business SEO"—drawing on anonymized aggregate data from thousands of audits. Publications write about data. Editors need it to substantiate claims in their articles. If you produce it, you get the links.
Expert commentary is the fastest to produce. Journalist request tools like Qwoted, Featured, and Help A Reporter Out (HARO's successor services) connect journalists seeking expert sources with subject matter experts. Respond consistently with specific, high-quality quotes (not generic platitudes) and you'll earn regular media mentions and links. Commit to responding to 3–5 relevant requests per week for 3 months—media mentions compound as journalists who've quoted you before return for future stories.
Tools and calculators are evergreen linkable assets. A free ROI calculator, an SEO audit checklist template, or a site speed benchmark tool will earn links organically as bloggers and educators link to them as resources. These take meaningful upfront investment but produce links for years with no ongoing effort.
Broken Link Building: Systematic and Scalable
Broken link building remains one of the most reliable link acquisition tactics because the value exchange is clear: you're helping a webmaster fix a dead link on their site by suggesting your content as a replacement. There's no payment, no exchange—just a useful service that results in an editorial link.
The process: use Ahrefs, Semrush, or similar tools to find pages in your niche that link to dead URLs (404 pages). Filter for links from domains with DR 30+ for quality. Check if your existing content—or content you could reasonably create—is a genuine substitute for the dead resource. If it is, email the webmaster noting the broken link and suggesting your page as a replacement.
Conversion rates on broken link building outreach are typically 5–15%, much higher than cold guest post pitches, because the prospect is already aware they have a problem (a broken link) and you're solving it for them at no cost. Volume is the limiting factor—finding enough relevant broken link targets in your niche to run a sustained campaign requires dedicated research time. Budget 3–4 hours per week for a meaningful ongoing campaign.
Prioritize broken links on resource pages. Resource pages ("Top Tools for X," "Best Guides to Learn Y") are high-value targets because they exist specifically to link to useful resources. If a resource page in your niche has a broken link, and you have a page that belongs on that list, your replacement pitch has extremely high acceptance rates.
Link Reclamation: Free Authority You're Leaving on the Table
Before building new links, recover the ones you've already earned. Link reclamation is the process of finding unlinked brand mentions (sites that reference your business without linking to it) and requesting that the link be added.
Set up Google Alerts and a mention monitoring tool (Brand24, Mention.com) for your brand name, your key products, and your unique data points. When you find a mention without a link, email the author noting that you appreciate the mention and asking if they'd be willing to add a link to the relevant page on your site. Acceptance rates are high because you're already in their content—they clearly have no objection to referencing you.
Also check for 301 redirect chains that are losing link equity. If a page you've redirected is still earning backlinks pointing to the original URL, and that URL goes through multiple redirect hops before reaching the live page, you're losing a portion of the link equity at each hop. Clean up redirect chains so every valuable inbound link resolves directly to a live page.
Check your link profile for links to pages that now return 404 or have been redirected away from the original content. These are "dead links" to your site—you've already earned the link, but the equity isn't being properly attributed because the destination no longer exists or has moved. Create 301 redirects from all historically linked URLs to the most relevant currently live page.
Realistic Expectations and Quality Over Volume
One mistake we see clients make after reading about link building is expecting to earn dozens of links per month through manual outreach. The reality: a disciplined link building program that produces 6–12 high-quality links per month—from DR 40+ domains with editorial standards—is an excellent result and will meaningfully move competitive rankings over a 6–12 month period.
The metric that matters isn't the number of links. It's the quality-adjusted link growth rate vs. your competitors. Check your top-ranking competitors' link acquisition over time. If your main competitor is earning 20 links per month from strong domains, you need to close that gap. If they're earning 3–5, modest consistent outreach is sufficient to overtake them.
Diversify your link profile as you build. Vary anchor text to include branded terms, exact-match keywords, partial-match keywords, and generic anchors. Any anchor text pattern that looks unnatural—such as 60% of acquired links using the exact target keyword—will trigger scrutiny. Editorial links rarely use exact-match anchors because editors write naturally.
Link building in 2026 rewards patience, genuine value creation, and systematic execution more than it ever has. The tactics that still work—digital PR, broken link building, expert commentary, link reclamation—all share the same underlying principle: they produce links because a real editor or webmaster made a voluntary decision to link to you. Build for editability, not volume, and your link profile will strengthen your rankings durably rather than putting them at risk.
Want this done for you?
Our team handles everything in this article—and more—for your site every month.
Book a Free Strategy Call